Poker Face Season 2 Review - A Bonkers, Brilliant Masterclass In Murder, Mischief, and Mystery

Peacock's Poker Face Season 2 doesn’t just stick the landing—it cartwheels across it, juggling flaming knives of genre and tone with ease. This thrilling second outing of Rian Johnson and Natasha Lyonne’s lie-sniffing roadshow mystery series gleefully dials up the chaos, crafting an episodic rollercoaster where each stop introduces unforgettable characters, seemingly impossible crimes, and an endless supply of jaw-dropping guest stars.

Every Episode a Wild Ride of Whodunnit Reinvention

What makes Poker Face sing is its refusal to play by the genre's rules. Each episode in Season 2 feels like its own short film, a stylish detour into increasingly outrageous yet astonishingly grounded situations—from a big box store Black Friday heist to a class pet conspiracy to a con artist caper gone sideways. The writing remains gloriously inventive, constantly pivoting tone and pace without ever losing its emotional grip. The show’s commitment to making every “howcatchem” feel different is unmatched, and the more unhinged it gets, the more you buy in.

Natasha Lyonne Is the Human Lie Detector of Our Dreams

As Charlie Cale, Natasha Lyonne continues to be TV’s coolest and most chaotic straight man. Whether she’s front and center or subtly supporting the story, Lyonne seamlessly shifts gears to become whatever each episode needs her to be. Her gift lies in anchoring the most absurd scenarios with heart, humor, and a genuine human curiosity that makes even the weirdest small-town murder feel personal. Lyonne’s optimism isn’t just a character trait—it’s the soul of the series.

The Best Guest Cast on Television, Period

Poker Face’s rolodex of talent remains peerless. Season 2 is bursting with one-off performances from an outrageous roster: Cynthia Erivo, Giancarlo Esposito, Kumail Nanjiani, Melanie Lynskey, Simon Helberg, Haley Joel Osment, Method Man, Patti Harrison, and so many more. It’s a true flex that the show not only attracts big names, but gives them juicy material to chew on in tight 60-minute plots. No one phones it in here.

The creativity behind each guest role is staggering. Cynthia Erivo delivers a tour-de-force performance playing not one, not two, but five sisters—each with her own distinct energy and secrets. Kumail Nanjiani turns in an inspired performance as the most “Florida Man” of Florida Men, complete with croc shoes, impulsive schemes, and a surprisingly tragic arc. Method Man gets to play a hilariously washed-up former action star, while Patti Harrison somehow makes a faux science fair feel like an existential meltdown. Every guest star swings for the fences—and hits.

Whip-Smart Writing with a Bonkers Brain

The beauty of Poker Face is how it turns the whodunnit on its head, then asks, “Why should Charlie care?” That question unlocks a narrative framework where each twist isn’t just clever—it’s character-driven. The writing walks a tightrope between noir, slapstick, and social commentary, often within the same scene. One moment it’s digging into dark themes like corporate greed or online disinformation, and the next it’s tossing in a perfectly timed pratfall or meta joke about genre conventions. The series never loses sight of its emotional compass—no matter how outlandish a story gets, it’s always rooted in a human truth that Charlie can’t ignore.

More impressively, the season escalates its weirdness without losing credibility. A man being crushed by a stuffed moose shouldn't feel logical, yet it fits. A murder plot involving cloned reptiles and a megachurch? Somehow entirely plausible. The series earns its absurdity through tightly woven setups, razor-sharp dialogue, and a deep understanding of cause and effect. It's chaotic, yes—but never careless.

A Must-Watch for Mystery Junkies and Genre Nerds Alike

Whether you're in it for the puzzle, the people, or the punchlines, Poker Face Season 2 delivers tenfold. It’s hard to name another show that makes each episode feel like a reinvention of the last while still threading a consistent emotional arc. For fans of smart television that knows how to have fun—Poker Face remains unbeatable. Which is why my Poker Face Season 2 review gets a

10/10

Poker Face Season 2 premieres on Thursday, May 8, 2025, exclusively on Peacock.

---

About Poker Face Season 2

Release Date: May 8, 2025 Creator / Writer / Director / Executive Producer: Rian Johnson 

Executive Producer / Director / Writer / Star: Natasha Lyonne 

Showrunner / Executive Producer: Tony Tost 

Executive Producer / Director: Adam Arkin

Executive Producers: Ram Bergman, Nena Rodrigue, Nora Zuckerman, Lilla Zuckerman 

Studio: T-Street and MRC 

Produced By: T-Street and Animal Pictures 

Genre/Format: Mystery/Comedy, 12 Ep x 60 Min  Poker Face is a mystery-of-the-week series following Natasha Lyonne’s Charlie, who has an extraordinary ability to determine when someone is lying. She hits the road with her Plymouth Barracuda and with every stop encounters a new cast of characters and strange crimes she can’t help but solve.  Synopsis Poker Face is a mystery-of-the-week series following Natasha Lyonne’s Charlie, who has an extraordinary ability to determine when someone is lying. She hits the road with her Plymouth Barracuda and with every stop encounters a new cast of characters and strange crimes she can’t help but solve. 

---

Are you hooked on Poker Face Season 2 yet? Which guest star blew your mind the most? What was your favorite bonkers murder scenario? And how does Natasha Lyonne keep getting cooler with every episode? Share your favorite guest star or mysteries with me in the comments or @me.